Scottish Girdle Scones are the perfect breakfast or teatime treat, light and fluffy, smothered in butter and honey. Amazon affiliate links have been used in this post to link to items I am discussing.
Hi. It’s me. I know I disappeared. Which is kind of ironic because except for doctors’ appointments and crossing our fingers and making a mad dash to a beach house in July, I have not left my house in eons. I feel like I should make some comment on what I have been doing or thinking about at home for the last six months but most of it is not fit for print. And I would like to keep my food blog a rage-free zone. Suffice to say like a lot of you I am angry. And having trouble focusing. And worrying, especially as a high risk person. Hopefully these scones will give you something happy to focus on for a few minutes.
A group of wonderful people that I have known online for eons now, dating back to the Cooking Light bulletin boards of all things, started a zoom book group during quarantine. We have ostensibly combined it with baking, but except for these scones I have not been very good at that. Anyway the first book we read was Jenny Colgan’s The Bookshop on the Corner: A Novel
At the same time, I had made friends with a new-ish neighbor. Which is weird during a pandemic I realize. We moved here around the same time but met each other because we were doing what everyone in quarantine was doing (who could), taking walks. Anyway, she was having a baby (that I never got to hold thank you very much Covid-19). What are the pandemic rules, I asked myself? Did I offer food, potentially offering our germs? Did I not offer food, ignoring a time in a family’s life when they most need the support of the community? Ack! I finally decided I would offer and leave it up to them, and they said yes. So in addition to an entree, I also doubled this recipe and sent over warm Scottish Girdle Scones, fresh from the oven.
People, I seriously miss feeding other people. Even if John was not Work From Home, I never send food into Google because Google already provides food. His job has seriously put a crimp in my baking especially! I miss feeding all those hungry college students.
At any rate, these Scottish Girdle Scones were amazing. The kind of amazing where you realize you should not make them often because not only are they amazing, but they taste best fresh from the cast iron pan, leading you to want to devour them all instantly. I recommend them for lazy Sunday brunches, company and sharing with neighbors. And if you just need something to distract you from the state of the world, I recommend them for that too. Thanks to Christina’s Cucina for the recipe I lightly adapted from.
Girdle, which according to my reading online is what a griddle is called in Scotland, just means the scones are cooked on your cooktop, not baked in the oven. Adapted from Christina's Cucina.
- 8 oz AP flour, plus more for rolling out
- 2 t baking powder
- 1/8 t fine sea salt
- 2 T sugar
- 2 T (1/4 stick; 1 oz) unsalted butter, cold
- 1/2 cup (4 oz) buttermilk (I prefer full fat for baking)
- 1 egg
- 1/4 cup currants*
-
Whisk together the flour, baking powder and salt. Set aside.
-
Cube the cold butter and place in a mixer with the sugar. Use a flat beater to combine--don't worry about it being perfect. You are not creaming this until light and fluffy.
-
Add the flour mixture and once again beat to combine.
-
Mix in the currants
-
Whisk together the buttermilk and egg until the egg is thoroughly emulsified into buttermilk. Then add the buttermilk mixture to the mixer bowl and beat until just combined.
-
Remove about half of the dough and pat it into a circle--be sure not to over-handle. Roll to about 3/4 inch thickness, and then use a biscuit cutter to cut into circles. I used a 2-inch diameter circle. Set aside on a platter for cooking. Repeat with remaining dough and when you are down to scraps just make a scone or 2 shaped with your hands that will not be perfect circles. Think of them as the cook's treat!
-
As with pancakes, it may take 1 or 2 scones the first time you make these to get the heat just right for your particular cooktop. Cast iron or enameled cast iron works best. If you are concerned use a little butter to grease the pan (if you use stainless steel, which I do not recommend, you may need a lot of butter which will change the final result). On my induction cooktop medium to slightly below medium heat worked best, although I started at a higher temperature. You will know it is ready when a little flour sprinkled on the surface turns light brown immediately.
-
Cook on the first side until the scone is raised and light brown on the bottom. Flip to cook until light brown on the other side and cooked all the way through. As with pancakes, you may need to slice into your first one to make sure you are getting it right, but after that it will go fast. And after that first one, you can cook more than one at a time, but do not overcrowd them or they will not rise properly or brown.
-
These scones in dough form felt quite heavy and then when they were done they were quite light. My best guess is from water evaporating.
-
Smother in butter and honey and devour immediately. Or take some to the neighbor wrapped in a towel.
*You can leave the currants out if you are going for more of a plain biscuit, but I love dried fruit in scones.
Looking for scones you bake in the oven? Check here!
I haven’t tried this yet, but they look and sound AMAZING.
A couple questions.
1) what is AP flour??
2) am I able to use just regular baking flour, if not what do u recommend??
AP flour is All Purpose flour–if you are in the US and cannot get AP flour I would recommend using about 2/3 bread flour and 1/3 cake flour. If you are not in the US, I guess it depends on what regular baking flour is! What matters the most is protein content–all purpose flour has less protein than bread flour but I think it is considered to have more protein than basic baking flour in Europe–although once again this can vary wildly by region and country. If you do have to use a higher protein flour, like bread flour, you will want to barely work the dough to avoid it becoming tough from gluten. I suspect a lower protein flour such as cake flour would work fine although if you try I would love it if you came back and let us know how it went.
A griddle in Scotland is called a griddle. A girdle is a piece of underwear that acts like ‘hold-me-in’ pants.
Hi: As someone interested in international food I am always open to learning new things. However, without knowing where you are from it is hard to know how to address this. For example, it is possible that in Edinburgh the more commonplace English griddle has overtaken the Scots girdle, but maybe not in the Highlands. I can tell you I found countless Girdle Scones online as well as a Scots Dictionary confirming that a girdle was indeed another word for a griddle. https://www.dsl.ac.uk/entry/snd/girdle
Sorry Sarah, you are quite wrong. Griddle is a recent English import
Sarah: Google “Scottish girdle”, that’s how it’s spelled!
8 ounces of flour makes 9 scones?????
It did for me, although I am sure this is affected by how thin you roll them and the diameter of your biscuit cutter. I do wish my recipe plug in would allow me to list a range, like 9-12, depending on size. Christina’s Cucina got 12 from the recipe I think.
I have been looking for a cast iron griddle scone recipe for so long. This one came out perfect. It made 9 two inch scones.
Thank you!
Is T tablespoon or teaspoon?
Hi, T is tablespoon. You can find answers to other questions like that on my FAQ page (not that I mind answering AT ALL, but I know recipe info is often time sensitive).
I made them using this recipe this morning…lovely! I used ordinary milk but I believe you can always add a teaspoon of apple cider vinegar to bring up the acid level, mine came out really nicely with just milk though. To my taste buds a tad more sugar is needed so I sprinkled some sugar on top, next time I’ll use 3Tbsn sugar.
Yes griddle or girdle! If you’re Scottish is a GIRDLE, a griddle is a newer/Anglicized version, please stick to the original for authenticity 🙂 A girdle pan is round with a handle that you could hang above a fire…as a side note…can you imagine how wonderful these would taste with a little woodsmoke built in?!!
A GIRDLE pan is also great/essential for making another Scottish classic….Tattie Scones! Thats my next kitchen experiment.
Yes I read a lot of Scottish historical fiction, so even before researching to double and triple check myself I knew it was girdle. I love Gaelic influenced English (not sure how else to put it, like bairn for children) so I agree, use the authentic term. And glad they turned out for you. I understand the urge to make them sweeter, but my daughter would prefer the opposite, so if I really want that sweet I will use honey butter on mine or something like that. But always cook to your taste is what I say.
Hi Laura. I grew up in New Zealand with these scones called girdle scones but they were cooked on a griddle. My husband grew up in Scotland and knew them as griddle scones. He has just made a batch and made into one circle and cut into triangles like a pizza. We think this is the traditional shape but everyone has different memories to look back on.
We made them on an electric pancake maker! Very non-traditional but it worked well. They are 100% delicious. Thank you for the recipe and a nostalgic look back to the past.
The pancake maker makes perfect sense! I am not sure I have ever seen one in America, but I am now intrigued. Growing up my mom had a big built in to the counter cast iron grill/griddle and the griddle would have been perfect for these scones. Whenever I have made oven scones, more like British scones, I have also sliced them into triangles. So this was a fun change for me.